Traditional or electronic?

[cloudberry]

I am currently using a 40 year old, basic upright but want something better.

I am attracted by Clavinovas - for the sound quality rather than the electronic gizmos. Do not have the room - or budget - for a full grand piano and even a good high string upright can be expensive, so Clavinova sounds a good option.

Only an enthusiastic amateur with little natural talent, just follow the dots and Willy's advice.;)

[williemyette]

A lot of people here use Clavinovas and they are very nice instruments.

Here is the realistic view (in my opinion):

Do you want to be a professional player? Do gigs, teach, etc.?: Get a grand piano.

Are you interested in playing but not interested in performing gigs? A keyboard is fine.

Now, if you get a keyboard, get "weighted" keys like a Clavinova.

The MIDI functions of a Clav are also a great learning tool. You can dload the MIDI files for the lessons and load them into the Clav!

Hope this helps